Alaska lawmakers travel to Barrow for gas line hearings

Originally published Tuesday, July 1, 2008 at 12:36 p.m.
Updated Tuesday, July 1, 2008 at 6:36 p.m.

North Slope Borough Mayor Edward Itta, left, talks with Rep. John Coghill Jr., R-North Pole, during a break in a special legislative session in Barrow, Alaska, on Tuesday, July, 1, 2008 to discuss TransCanada Corp.'s plan to build a gas pipeline under Gov. Sarah Palin's natural gas  pipeline proposal.
Piper Palin, Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin's 7-year-old daughter, gets tossed into the air from a ugruk or bearded seal, skin blanket during the season's last Nalukataq whaling festival in Barrow, Alaska, on Monday, June 30, 2008. The governor was in Barrow to meet with people as state legislators arrive in the Arctic Ocean town to discuss her natural gas pipeline proposal during a special legislative session that began on July, 1, 2008.
Tony Palmer, vice president of Alaska Development for TransCanada Corp., right, explains the company's plan to build a gas pipeline under Gov. Sarah Palin's natural gas pipeline  proposal to the Alaska Legislature during a special legislative session in Barrow, Alaska, on Tuesday July, 1, 2008.  Sen. Don Olson, D-Nome, back left, Reps. Ralph Samuels, R, Anchorage, Reggie Joule, D-Kotzebue, and  Sen. Bert Stedman, back right, listen.

BARROW -- Half the state's lawmakers came to this Arctic community — some grabbing as many as three flights to reach the nation's northernmost town — to continue a monthlong and statewide debate on a natural gas pipeline proposal.

On Tuesday, these 30 state representatives and senators resumed discussions on whether TransCanada Corp. should be issued an exclusive state license to build its proposed gas line.

It's a line that would ultimately carry trillions of cubic feet of natural gas from the nearby North Slope to Midwestern markets.

The natural gas fields, where the proposed multibillion-dollar project would be anchored, are about 300 miles away from the elementary school gymnasium where lawmakers met.

Lawmakers chose Barrow for the hearing because for 30 years, the region has produced the oil flowing down the trans-Alaska pipeline system.

That oil is currently responsible for about 90 percent of the state's treasury, but the fields are dwindling at about 6 percent production a year.

A natural gas pipeline is seen as a key component to keeping state coffers solvent, and a potential boost to this region's economic development.

This was not lost on community leaders and residents who got their chance to speak, or in some cases, speak out.

About two dozen longtime residents implored lawmakers to include the Arctic and coastal communities by requiring the hiring of local workers and making sure the project is environmentally responsible.

Many North Slope Borough leaders, including Mayor Edward Itta, support Gov. Sarah Palin's efforts of getting a pipeline built — a project under discussion for decades with little movement.

"Our future is dependent on broad-based economic support of a project of this significance," said longtime resident Ben Frantz. "It needs to get done.

"This project alone will not cure all ills, but we need to take this step and move onto other steps of significance."

Lawmakers have until Aug. 2 to take that next step by either supporting or rejecting TransCanada Corp.'s bid for a state license, but a vote is expected much sooner.

TransCanada is proposing a line that would travel 1,715 miles from the North Slope southeast to a pipeline hub in Calgary, Alberta, that connects to all the major markets on the continent.

But ConocoPhillips and BP PLC said they are moving forward with a competing pipeline, called Denali, outside the state's bid-requirement law that would afford TransCanada up to $500 million in seed money.

For some folks in Barrow, the gas line debate was a secondary topic because North Slope gas isn't expected to be in any pipeline for at least 10 years.

Many who spoke chose to address immediate issues: soaring energy costs; jobs; how offshore drilling will effect the whaling industry.

Property taxes from the trans-Alaska pipeline system have helped the North Slope Borough keep power costs down over the years, but it's still expensive compared the state's more urban areas.

Visitors are getting a taste of that sticker shock this week, especially when perusing local stores for perishable and dry goods. The costs are more than twice what people in other regions of Alaska pay, like shelling out $10 for a gallon of milk.

"Every time something costs a dollar in Anchorage, it costs a $1.89 in Barrow," said Debby Edwardson, who chairs the North Slope Borough school board.

"It's good they are here; this is where the resources come from. It's not often we are at the discussion table."

This week's session in Barrow is the fifth round of hearings outside of Juneau, and the first to be held off the state's road system.

Lawmakers traveled from as far away as Sitka (Republican Rep. Bert Stedman), the Aleutian Islands region (Democratic Rep. Bryce Edgmon) and from within the North Slope Borough itself, (Democratic Rep. Reggie Joule).

Some arrived Sunday night and began mingling with the community's 4,000-plus residents, most of whom are of Inupiat Eskimo descent. Part of the local festivities this week included a whaling festival.

Some lawmakers have questioned the costs of taking the hearings on the road to Barrow, estimating that it could push the cost of special sessions past $2 million.

The argument is that the Legislature could make better use of its time and money by taking a vote on the TransCanada's prospective license sooner rather than later, and not drag out the debate.

But as the upcoming vote is deemed one of the most important to be cast by a state lawmaker in decades and as concerns over energy costs are boiling over, others countered getting lawmakers out of Juneau and to far flung regions was essential.

"Yes, it's expensive, but sometimes ignorance is more expensive than knowing something about the people in your state," said Joule, who represents Barrow residents. "What we need to see are both ends of the spectrum.

"We need to see where the resource comes from, but we also have a responsible to go to those places that aren't as fortunate, where they need different kinds of resources and different kinds of help."

House Majority Leader Ralph Samuels, an Anchorage Republican making his first trip to Barrow, said such travel is simply "good government."

"The reality is when you make these policy decisions, you need to walk a mile in their shoes," Samuels said. "I think they should do this more often.

"If you can get 30 people to come up here, you've done something important. The problems up here are nothing like the problems of my constituents."

Lawmakers will return to Juneau for a second special session July 9 and are expected to quickly take a vote on Palin's recommendation to award TransCanada a license to proceed with a gas line project.

Community Discussion

Newsminer.com doesn't necessarily condone the comments here, nor does it review every post. Read our full user's agreement.

  1. out_in_the_cold
    7/1/2008, 3:06 p.m.
    Suggest removal

    Thank you to the Alaskan Legislators that took the time to listen to the People of Alaska. Hope you have a renewed sense that ALASKA is a big place with may different problems, BUT WE ARE ALL ALASKANS. And we all need affordable energy to survive Alaskan cold dark winters.

  2. mit
    7/1/2008, 5:35 p.m.
    Suggest removal

    If they are from south central, they don't give an Ice cube!

  3. DistantThunder
    7/1/2008, 5:48 p.m.
    Suggest removal

    Barrow gets a pretty good deal on their gas...
    ...all of Alaska should be so lucky.
    Now we know all of Alaska can be that lucky, real soon!!!
    Howz that???...plastic gaslines-&-fibreoptics everywhere.

    First Gasline Over the Brooks Wins!!!
    www.fairbanksgas.com

  4. ONAPA
    7/1/2008, 6:37 p.m.
    Suggest removal

    From the Article they need cheap milk in Barrow. If we could drop a milk crate there, and pick up a tank of gas we could set up a profitable delivery route.

    First Milktruck Over the Brooks Wins!!!

    But seriously, I wonder how much our legislature is going to warp the special session based on the feedback from these community meetings that aren't focused on AGIA.

    crash / stumble / grumble ....

  5. DistantThunder
    7/1/2008, 8:40 p.m.
    Suggest removal

    Eureka!
    A milk and honey pipeline from Alberta to Juneau, Fairbanks, and Barrow !!!
    ....I'll get to work on that right away !!!
    [very funny onapa !!]

    ...now let's see, if we packaged the milk and honey in ballistic-plastic cylinders and pneumatically fired them through a HDPE-pipe buried next to TC-gasline

    ..ya see, I toad ya there was many uses for Alaska's ethane to make plastics in Alaska !!!
    neener-neener!!!

    ....oops, I forgot the oatmeal

  6. ONAPA
    7/1/2008, 9:54 p.m.
    Suggest removal

    Careful DistantThunder we may stumble onto a formula for a perpetual motion line. Oatmeal expands when wet and creates heat, gas expands when heated... ok that's as far as my 8th grade science degree can take me.

  7. out_in_the_cold
    7/1/2008, 10:52 p.m.
    Suggest removal

    ONAPA and DistantTunder: Watch out, if we get a leak in your perpetual motion lines, they will be calling Alaska "The Land of Milk and Honey". But, I wonder if we could substitute Delta Barley for the Oatmeal?

    Come on Legislators, LET'S GET A GAS PIPE LINE BUILT, starting right after the 4th of July fireworks.

  8. DistantThunder
    7/2/2008, 5:48 a.m.
    Suggest removal

    Barley?

    barley = beer

    we pour in 100tcf of gas into Canada, and the lower48 gets 100tcf of beer out at the bottom...

    ....I'm heading down to the tavern for breakfast before onapa invents a new way to store methane in ice-cream

    you'll know where to find me if the pipeline action starts

    beer & bicycles.... hard times

    .....splash/gurgle

  9. tattoohombre
    7/2/2008, 6:48 a.m.
    Suggest removal

    You guy's just made my morning! ha! ha! ha! Good stuff!

Post a comment

Commenting requires registration.

Username:
Password: (Forgotten your password?)

Comment:

Also inside
Today's news / Photos / Local / Alaska / Sports / Opinion
Features
Sundays / Health / Food / Outdoors / Latitude 65 / Youth / Business
newsminer.com
Archives / About / Feedback / Privacy Policy / User Agreement / Jobs / Contact / Feeds / Bookstore
Submit
Letters to the Editor / Events / Obituaries
Alaska Web design by Verticentric Design