Injured in a fall, 83-year-old nurse survives five-day ordeal
by dermotcole
 Dermot Cole
3 months ago | 3873 views | 14 14 comments | 19 19 recommendations | email to a friend | print | permalink
The story of what happened to Alaska nurse Pauline Hardy on Halloween is heartbreaking.

At the very least, it seems that the Alaska State Troopers need to review their procedures when a person inside a home is thought to be incapacitated.

In addition, this story serves as a reminder of the value of the Lifeline emergency call system.

Hardy, 83, was in her house at Anchor Point that day when she fell and was unable to get up and answer the phone, her daughter Mary Tony says.

Tony has written to the governor and all 60 legislators detailing what happened to her mom. She says she never wants this to happen to anyone else.

Tony, who lives in Fairbanks, said she called the Troopers in Homer on the Tuesday after Halloween when Tony and her siblings were unable to contact their mother on the phone.

She said a trooper went to the house, but would not go inside. The house was dark and her car was in the driveway.

 

She said she begged the trooper to break down the door because she was sure something had happened to her mom.

After a series of calls to Tony and her siblings, the trooper told her a locksmith would have to come by in the morning, she said.

“I was deeply upset and begged him in tears to just break the door or window down and see if my mother was lying on the floor in need of help. He staunchly refused because his superior would not allow him,” she said.

 ”The next day, I was able to contact a family friend, Madelaine Pruitt, who immediately went over, found the door unlocked and went in to find my mother still alive on the floor in the pantry. She said the trooper must not have tried the door handle very hard because it opened easily for her.”

Hardy remains in the hospital, where she is recovering slowly, her daughter said.

“It is a miracle she survived and a testament to the strength and spirit of the pioneers of our state,” Tony said.

“My mother is a registered nurse, she came to Alaska in 1948 and served as a nurse to hospitals in Kodiak, Anchorage, Juneau, Dillingham, and Fairbanks. She was a community health aide in St. Marys for a brief time. She cared for children of the TB epidemic, chronic inebriates at alcohol treatment centers, and the mentally ill who were hospitalized. She raised and homeschooled her four children as a single mother in a remote log cabin she built.

“Three of those four children have college degrees. People would come to our cabin for medical care or to bring letters for her to read to help them understand and she would type letters of reply for them. She helped organize the native village during the ANSCA by serving as a secretary at the meetings. She grew up in Maine and is hardworking, independent, cares deeply for others and is of great faith,” Tony said.

 ”In her retirement, she has devoted herself to concern for the emergency services personnel—troopers, coast guard, and emts, and has spent her days praying for their safety on calls. She refused a lifeline call button because she was afraid she would accidentally push it and the EMTs would have to come on icy roads and be put in danger. She has spent her life in service of others. She does not deserve to be treated like she was by the troopers and left to lie on her floor without food or water,” she wrote.

 ”My sister and I live in Fairbanks, one brother lives in Anchorage and one brother in Nikolai. We are unable to afford to go to stay at the hospital in Homer to be near her during her recovery and we are trying to get her moved to Denali Center in Fairbanks where we can visit her until she is well enough to leave the hospital,” Tony said.

 ”Let me end with this: the way my mother raised me and the way the spirit of Alaska is for me-if each of your mothers was injured, lying alone on the floor in the dark of her house, I would not hesitate to break the door down if you called me to check on her," she said.

"The Alaska I grew up in was a place we took care of each other.”

The governor’s office is looking into the matter. So is the head of the Alaska State Troopers. They didn’t want to comment until their inquiries are completed.

Rep. John Harris included the gist of the letter in his latest newsletter. He says that Alaska is still a place where people show care for each other. Harris said he intends to follow up on the situation.

I hope that Hardy gets well soon. 

 

 

comments (14)
« tlb63 wrote on Wednesday, Nov 25 at 02:21 PM »
I am so saddened by this. I also have a family member living in Anchor Point and could easily have been in this situation. My thoughts and prayer are with this family and most especially Pauline Hardy.
report abuse
« gondar wrote on Wednesday, Nov 25 at 11:05 AM »
My first reaction was outrage. After reflection however, I don't believe I should demand the state should check on or care for my 83 year mother. That responsibility should fall to me. Or, in this case, to YOU, Mary Tony.
report abuse
« whattheheck wrote on Wednesday, Nov 25 at 07:16 AM »
My observation is also that the current generation of troopers don't have much interest in doing anything that doesn't involve arresting somebody. They seem to escalate situations rather than defusing them, and they place themselves into "deadly force warranted" situations way too often. The old Protect and Serve mindset seems to have been replaced with a Rambo mindset.
report abuse
« Pearl=W wrote on Tuesday, Nov 24 at 02:56 PM »
Sparticus has the right of it, based on my own knowledge and experience.

Also, Artic Lynx's experience is by NO MEANS unique. The Troopers have *no* problem committing even clearly illegal entries and searches, when they want to. chelly4 is just making excuses - it's his job.

I think the emphasis of the Troopers has shifted, in the last decade or so, from providing/protecting public safety, to a more militaristic, arbitrary, and selective 'enforcement' role. [That is, they are highly selective about which laws they choose to enforce, (or obey), when, and for/against whom] And I don't think this shift is beneficial for the public at large.
report abuse
« Arctic_Lynx wrote on Tuesday, Nov 24 at 10:49 AM »
Odd. This summer when my neighbor passed away in a cabin 30 feet away from mine. The troopers decided they needed to enter my place, with no rational explanation why. They picked the lock and got in despite the fact there was no evidence that any one had been there recently. Technically that was illegal entry, as there was no probable cause for an entry.

Also in the past troopers have been known to kick doors in if a persons safety is questioned, under the rational that doors are cheap and replaceable, when people aren't.

So it seems the troopers have different levels entry around the state.
report abuse
« Rockee wrote on Tuesday, Nov 24 at 09:51 AM »
Sparticus, you're the one I want on the job!!!

Dukit22, she was within reason to refuse the button--and if law enforcement had done their job, this wouldn't be an issue.
report abuse
« dukit22 wrote on Tuesday, Nov 24 at 09:36 AM »
How sad. But please remember the writers comment that the person involved REFUSED A LIFE LINE. Whatever her reasons, she refused the single button that would have totally avoided the problem
report abuse
« anonymous wrote on Tuesday, Nov 24 at 09:36 AM »
report abuse
« TheAntiClinger wrote on Tuesday, Nov 24 at 08:12 AM »
If I need a trooper I'll just mumble something about all the chronic I have growing in the closet. Several troopers and a dog will be here in a flash.
report abuse
« Sparticus wrote on Monday, Nov 23 at 11:51 PM »
I am commenting on this article because this is an issue I deal with on a regular basis. I work as a paramedic, and routinely deal with this situation (what we call a welfare check). The Troopers behavior was grossly negligent if not malfeasant in nature. I apologize deeply to the family. I have gone through many doors looking for people in this same scenario- because that is what I and the troopers are paid for.

As for chelly4’s comment, she is a little misguided. There is no double edged sword. Any competent person can determine who the caller is, so “malicious rescues” don’t happen. It is pretty easy to check phone numbers and addresses and determine who is who. No, the home owner is not going to shoot anybody because it is clearly the duty of public safety to identify themselves. Knocking and shouting are more than enough to alert a homeowner to our presence. No one is surprised, at least not surprised enough to shoot. (Really? Shooting? We wear clearly identifiable uniforms and are not exactly stealthy, and we shout Paramedics, Fire Dept or Police when we knock, and the homeowner can usually see the emergency vehicles outside the window.) Yes the troopers CAN enter if a perceived emergency is taking place (say an 83 year old woman on the floor injured and sick) HOWEVER they generally can not arrest you for what they find. So Chelly4 is half right. These incidents are not intended to be a criminal search, but a rescue.

If you are really that paranoid of police power call the ambulance, as a paramedic I can not arrest you. Anchor point has a fire department and ambulance service. THEY should have been notified as well. Why they were not, I do not know. It was clear that a medical emergency was anticipated by the daughter, why was an ambulance not sent as well? I have many questions, which I will be asking the appropriate officials.

I sincerely apologize to Ms. Hardy that this happened, and publicly chastise the State Trooper involved, as I have an 89 year old grandmother who easily could have been Ms Hardy

report abuse
« buboy wrote on Monday, Nov 23 at 10:06 PM »
Sad, very sad. For the past two weeks the troopers have been swarming gold stream road and the Fox area. They ain't looking to help anyone. They are fishing for revenue tickets. They park on private roads and land.
report abuse
« tompat wrote on Monday, Nov 23 at 07:28 PM »
How sad the Alaska State Troopers can not help to check on an old person, But if your vehicle was disabled along the road, they can & will come to your house to see if alcohol was involved. To serve & protect BULL!!
report abuse
« chelly4 wrote on Monday, Nov 23 at 05:24 PM »
This is very much a double edged sword, and law enforcement is damned if they do, damned if they don't. This story gives a good example of damned if they don't. But if they do, and the person making the call was lying (not really their relative, or mad at their relative and trying to get them in trouble for having a drug operation, etc.) and law enforcement makes entry, everyone is mad that they entered a person's home without probable cause. Or even if the person making the call really had good intentions, and the "sick" family member just didn't want to talk to them any more (I've heard of this happening several times). In a worst case scenario (which is what law enforcement has to expect), the trooper goes in, and the homeowner, either because they over react or they are mentally unstable due to age or other reason, they pull out a gun and the trooper defends himself with deadly force. Now he has shot a homeowner, and it will be argued by many that he had no legal reason to be in the house. From a liability point of view, no matter how justified he is in defending himself, if the court finds he had no reason to be in the house, he is wrong in having used deadly force. Not saying the trooper shouldn't or couldn't have done more to look into this, but it is not as one sided as it is made out to be. The courts have been quite clear that law enforcement needs a good reason to enter a person's home without a warrant. Exigent circumstances is an accepted reason, but there have to be enough facts present to justify exigent circumstances.
report abuse
« Rockee wrote on Monday, Nov 23 at 03:58 PM »
My thoughts and prayers are with this family. I'm curious as to the law enforcement supervisor's reasoning behind not allowing the officer to complete a welfare check on an elderly woman? Sad, sad, sad.
report abuse