Why do potato chips cost $4.29 in Anchorage and $9.99 in Bethel?
by dermotcole
 Dermot Cole
Nov 29, 2011 | 5954 views | 21 21 comments | 16 16 recommendations | email to a friend | print | permalink

The critical analysis of the bypass mail program asserts that rural residents are not seeing the benefits they should be from the program.

The Inspector General's office, which serves as an ombudsman of sorts for the post office, cites potato chip prices as an example.

In Anchorage, a 14-ounce bag of Ruffles was selling for $4.29 a year ago in October. In Bethel, the same bag was marked at $9.99 in both of the stores in Bethel, which is a bypass mail hub.

If the stores in Bethel shipped potato chips as part of a 1,000-pound delivery, the cost of getting the chips to Bethel would be as low as 35 cents, the report says.

The Bethel stores are not paying the Anchorage retail price, so the markup is far more than 100 percent, the IG said.

"Other examples abound. Anchorage residents pay $3.49 for Colgate toothpaste (5.8 ounces), which might cost as little as 14 cents to ship, but Bethel residents pay $4.59 at the local stores. Similarly, Bethel merchants mark up a large tin of coffee by 100 percent over costs. While there are limited exceptions to this phenomenon — milk in Bethel costs less than retail milk in Anchorage — the overall trend of extraordinarily high prices at rural merchants is supported by statistics from the Alaska Department of Labor and Workforce Development, which reports prices for a market basket of  groceries.

"In small remote villages serviced by Alaska Bypass, the grocery prices seem to bear little relationship to the cost of getting the products there and may include a variety of other factors."

The report says that a "wide variety" of commercial interests are the big beneficiaries of bypass mail, including airlines and stores.

 

 

 

 

Comments
(21)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
walk-in
|
December 01, 2011
They could have picked a better example for the specific item they wanted to compare prices on. How many people know that most of the airplanes delivering bypass mail are unpressurized? Guess what happens to a bag of potato chips at altitude in an unpressurized airplane? I'll give you a hint...they don't stay in the bag. To get around that particular problem, we built potato chip transport containers. When you talk about the price of a bag of potato chips in the village, you might want to take into consideration the man-hours and other costs involved in manufacturing a pressurized container specifically for the purpose of transporting potato chips so that the bags don't explode in flight. Critics of bypass mail who assume that it is designed only to benefit the air carriers don't have an even rudimentary understanding of the costs and technical difficulties involved for the carriers. Any attempt to artificially control the price will result in worse service and lost jobs.
WalkersMillions
|
November 30, 2011
Need a house in rural AK? The gov't has a subsidy for you. Need power at rates better than Fairbanks? Subsidy. Shipping supplies? Subsidy. Air transportation? Subsidy.

There used to be a time rural Alaskans were self sufficient. That day is over. Now, they are like everywhere else in Alaska - living off government. But just to be clear: why is it the responsibility of the federal income tax payer and State tax payers (oil companies) to subsidize the residency choice of every Alaskan? If me and 13 buddies want to start a rural village or city in the middle of nowhere, why is it every one else's responsibility to ensure that I have an energy-efficient home, access to health care, power, and subsidized shipping and transportation to my chosen location?

There are no jobs in many of these areas because there is nothing there. Why are we propping them up?
twain
|
November 29, 2011
Roadie..... I wouldnt be against price controls if the capitalists flatly refused to stop their gouging. FDR had to resort to that during ww2 to keep the war profiteers from breaking the country....and they hated him for it.

Its ironic that you mentioned high cost of insurance when you consider that insurance companies by law are exempt from the anti trust law that keeps companies from meeting in private and set prices or policies that give them a monopoly. Yes thats right insurance companies can legally meet in private and SET prices.

So your decrying regulations is bogus...we really need MORE regulations of these crooks and the will to enforce them.
Mr.roadtrip
|
November 29, 2011
If AC co. is making such obscene profits whats to stop someone else from opening their own store that charges less and takes all the business?

Answer, thousands upon thousands of govt regulations, high fuel costs, the price of insurance is astronomical, and taxes.

So whats your solution twain? Price controls, central planning, more regulations and taxes? What?

blue5011
|
November 29, 2011
How about potato chip subsidies?
Lt.FrankDrebin
|
November 29, 2011
In America, the cost of goods and services is usually whatever the market will bear. If people in the village don't want to pay the high prices, then stop drinking soda and eating potato chips and start eating only healthy foods that cost less and are supplemented with wild game.
Arcticteacher
|
November 29, 2011
I am a teacher in an Alaskan bush village. My observation is that most of the children and families in my village are healthy eaters. No fast food, limited junk food, and wholesome homemade meals of subsistance meat and fish. Many people still bake their own bread. Very few people in the village are obese. We have one small store. It has 4 aisles, 2 chest freezers, and a fridge. Costs are high, I guess when the next closest store is 300 miles away you suck it up and pay. We seldom get fresh fruits, veggies, and dairy and when it comes it is a special treat. Because it is perishable it cannot be shipped as bypass. I don't understand why some people think that those of us living in the villages eat a lot of junkfood in place of a healthy diet.
Steve_Estes
|
November 30, 2011
Arcticteacher:

One of the people that think those living in the bush eats junk food is the Inspector General's office. But, the Inspector General's office also thinks they buy tooth paste.

Can Inspector General's office explain why I pay $0.59 for a bottle of water at Sam's Club, $1.59 for a bottle of water at my local convenience store, and $2.59 at the Airport ?

Is it the shipping ?

Nope. It's whatever the market will bear.
captcrunch
|
November 29, 2011
The profits are higher than the examples given, AC does not buy at regular stores in the city, they buy wholesale and ship it by-pass mail then mark it up 200% and rip off the villagers..some village residents are ordering thru bush ordering business's paying the freight or regular mailing and still save 50% over their local stores. The only people benefiting from by-pass mail are the commercial companys.
Lance_Roberts
|
November 29, 2011
If a business doesn't pay their bills and make enough profit to live on and make it worth all the work, then they will go out of business. The biggest reason for higher prices in the bush is that they have so few customers, the volume is low, so they get no economies of scale. The other reasons are their costs, as inchworm pointed out.

I sure wish liberals would get some economic educating; they should all be required to be in business for a while, so they understand reality a little. But in the end, they have no logic or facts, so they just call people names, like they were in grade school.
islandliver
|
November 29, 2011
Lance I've been in a few businesses and your knowledge is far from complete. Have you ever seen a P&L from these stores? What is their gross margin compared to similar businesses in other locations. For gross margin is a measure of a business ability to make a profit.

It has nothing to do with liberal or conservative when you look at the numbers. You can take the retail cost of an item in Anchorage add the air freight cost and determine the landed in village cost. Now the retail cost in Anchorage includes a profit for the retailer. While near wholesale price is what these village stores buy for. For none of these stores simply buy off the shelf and pay full retail. Many good in these villages are over twice what the item cost plus freight. And it not all due to higher wages and utilities.

twain
|
November 29, 2011
Its called greedy, rogue capitalism my teabagger friends. The same type of capitalist pigs that sre developing your oil kingdom. Charge whatever you can get away with and if anyone complains you can depend on the good old right wingers to come forward with the old song of they have to charge that to stay in business. The more crazy of the bunch will try to blame it on the liberals. Seems we have seen this movie before ...there was an intermission in 2008, but the movie continues. You can be assured you will not like the end of this movie if this runaway greed is allowed to continue.
1TarBaby
|
November 29, 2011
The cost of doing doing business is very high. Telephone, electricity, fuel, statutory mandated labor costs - Obama care, worker's comp, minimum wage law, inventory control -someone needs to keep track of stock, and fill out government required paper work, price rigging between the stores, dead beats who don't pay their bill, shoplifting, low volume, spoilage.

All of these costs are added on to the retail price.

The inspector general does not have clue re the actual cost of doing business and expects the stores have cost plus 10% mark up in his Washington DC dream world of Utopian socialism.

Also, it's his job to rationalize elimination of the program to save money to continue paying extravagant wages and employee benefits to Post Office management and staff. A $70 million savings is zip out of $9 billion dollar loss.

This is all just picking at low hanging fruit while ignoring golden union contracts beyond his reach and power to pick.

PSWhat's the markup on a Stamp?

blue5011
|
November 29, 2011
"just picking at low hanging fruit"

Got to start somewhere... Bring a ladder, we'll start higher up in the tree.
Mr.roadtrip
|
November 28, 2011
That's the problem with liberals. They want thousands upon thousands of govt regulations, they want high fuel costs, they want to litigate everything so the price of insurance is astronomical, and they want to tax the rich. And then they complain when the price of everything goes up.

SomethingForNothing
|
November 28, 2011
Yep, and the CONs want to have less regulation on the banks and wall street---gosh that worked so well in 2008 didn't it?; they want the government to subsidize their heating and fuel costs---but they don't want to pay for it; they want to limit the individuals right to access to the courts, but not the corps access to them---most lawsuits, btw, are business vs. business; and they think the Walton family and koch bros and hedgefund mgrs should pay the same tax as someone earning $30,000 a year; and, finally, CONs never complain....
Mr.roadtrip
|
November 29, 2011
"they want the government to subsidize their heating and fuel costs---but they don't want to pay for it", What? Fuel is 4 bucks a gallon here and pushing 8 bucks out in the bush. Do you think that the govt graciously allowing us to drill for oil on our own land amounts to a subsidy? Is that what you think?

Ever heard of supply and demand? How about class envy? Hope and Change? Any of that ring a bell for you?

islandliver
|
November 28, 2011
The price in these location is simply greed. Business all over make it based on markup that are no where near with these village stores can get away with. The potato chip example is perfect for showing you the gouging. And all the by-pass mail is providing is a greater profit margin for a few merchants.

By-pass mail is the biggest ripoff ever conceived by a few politicains who used the USPS to get them re-elected. It sound so nice and human to provide mail to these poor individuals living in a remote location where they can not make it without help. I'm sure the only problem passing the legislation was finding out what give-a-ways in other states our Alaskan delegates had to support to get this implemented. For nothing in DC get through without shaping my vote for your support. I believe this mess is a legacy of Uncle Ted's making.
inchworm
|
November 28, 2011
I agree that the discrepancy between the cost of bypass mail and the mark-up on products is concerning, but higher shipping costs are not the only costs of business that stores are passing along to customers. Everything costs more in rural communities, particularly energy. Higher electric and fuel costs are passed on to customers through higher product costs in store, as are other expenses such as wages, benefits, maintenance, etc. It's really a snowball effect.
inupiatologist
|
November 28, 2011
I would certainly like to see Civil Aeronautical Board investigates the price per distance in the rural air traffic system. What are they charging freight? Please get off Wash.D.C weather and come to rural setting area.
dave1013
|
November 29, 2011
Hey braintrust, the CAB went out of business in 1978 when the airlines got deregulated.

What's your next irrelevant suggestion?
Newsminer.com encourages a lively exchange of ideas regarding topics in the news. Users are solely responsible for the content. Comments are not pre-approved by News-Miner staff. Please keep it clean, respect others and use the 'report abuse' link when necessary. Read our full user's agreement.