Kaltag fish processing plant closes for summer
by Reba Lean / rlean@newsminer.com
Jul 12, 2011 | 2431 views | 8 8 comments | 13 13 recommendations | email to a friend | print
FAIRBANKS — A Yukon River fish processing plant at Kaltag that was named one of the “greenest fisheries” in the world is closing its doors this summer.

The operator of the plant blamed a fishing time limit imposed by the Alaska Department of Fish and Game, a limit he believes is unnecessary because his business does not target the depleted king salmon run. However, a manager said the department had to impose the limit to protect king salmon and treat fishermen along the river equitably.

Doug Karlberg, owner of Yukon River Gold, said the department’s limit left him with too little time to make money. He leases the plant from the city of Kaltag.

“In order for that plant to survive, it needs about 35 days of processing time,” he said.

Yukon kings begin swimming up the river before the summer chums, but the two runs usually overlap for a few weeks. Regulators only allowed the fishwheels that supply the Yukon River Gold plant to begin operating once the kings had passed the Kaltag area. That gave the plant about 20 days to work on the remaining portion of the chum run, and it wasn’t enough to pay the bills, Karlberg said.

“We don’t have any more money to lose,” he said.

“I was forced to close it down,” Karlberg said. “And now we have a record chum run in the Yukon River and the people are having to sit there with no jobs.”

The seasonal plant employs about 70 workers from villages in the area. Many are high school students. The plant operated for four years.

Karlberg buys only chum salmon from local fishwheels. Those wheels are monitored so any other types of fish, including king salmon, are immediately thrown back in the Yukon River — alive and unharmed, Karlberg said. The low bycatch prompted Fisheries International magazine, in its January edition, to name the Kaltag plant one of the best fisheries in the world.

For two years, Fish and Game stationed observers in Kaltag to watch the fishwheel and processing operation. Last year, Karlberg said, the observers saw there was no king bycatch.

The department’s area manager, Steve Hayes, said that’s not quite the case. “There has been some bycatch taken,” he said.

Hayes said he can’t tell Yukon River subsistence fishermen that “every king counts, and they can’t catch them” if he doesn’t tell the same thing to commercial fishermen that supply Yukon Gold.

Severe restrictions have been imposed on subsistence king salmon fishing along the Yukon River this year, Hayes said.

During four of the past five years, he said, the Yukon River did not meet the king salmon escapement goals established by a treaty with Canada. Hayes said about half the Yukon’s king salmon spawn in Canada’s waters.

“We’ve had to be very conservative trying to protect these kings,” he said. “Unfortunately, because of that, we’ve had to let a surplus of chum up the river.”

Hayes said Fish and Game met with Karlberg this spring and said his operation could open in the last week of June, a week earlier than last year but still well after the summer chums began passing Kaltag.

“As far as commercial fishing for chum, I think it could have been a very viable thing this summer,” Hayes said.

Karlberg said the plant has year-round bills to pay. It is now closed for the summer and will be reviewed this fall by Fish and Game and the local economic development corporation.

“We will leave the door open for federal and state managers to change their policies over the summer,” Karlberg wrote in a press release. “If they change these policies, enabling economic viability of this plant, we will be delighted to reopen the plant in 2012.”
Comments
(8)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Man_from_Unk
|
July 14, 2011
blogger 'doubledumb' points out the fishery in the sea, and yes, I agree that the problems with the King Salmon declines started with the pollock fishery ByCatch. The North Pacific Fisheries Management Council placed a 60,000 King Salmon Bycatch limit on them in 2009 and that limit took effect this year FINALLY! If the State Management can place EMERGENCY CLOSURES on land based fishers, then the Federal Management should do the same when the pollock fishery ByCatch hits about 15,000 Kings. But again, who is to say that those ByCatch numbers are accurate anyway - they don't have observers 24/7 in the pollock fishery. If anybody should give, it's them.
Man_from_Unk
|
July 14, 2011
It's too bad that this small business had to close down due to mismanagement or lying or both.

Perhaps the state should put the salmon managers in seasonal jobs - ain't no salmon running in the wintertime anyway. Then and only then will they understand the hardships the poor people endure when all they have for a little income is a seasonal job. That'll save the state some bucks to put toward something more useful like restoration efforts.
ryemil
|
July 13, 2011
Guess I better finish my comment, also Doug K. pulled out(lack of money)before Steve Hayes made up the lie about letting the 'kings go by to be equal for everyone', Steve Hayes has been in the Ak. Dep of Fish & Game long enough that he should know by now that in 'Y4- the kings run on the South bank & the summer chums run on the North bank,' if he doesn't know, could someone please tell him. To 'treat the fishermen equitably', then F&G needs to make some changes in openings in Y1, Y2 & Y3- if F&G has paid very much attention on subsistence at the lower Yukon, they would have noticed that they have their subsistence fish usually before half the king season is over. To make it more equitably(as Steve said) what needs to be done is to have 2 nine hour/wk openings of the fist 2 1/2 weeks, then after that go to two 24 or 36 hour openings/wk. Last year the lower Yukon fishermen said that they were enjoying fishing their local kings during the commerial openings. It sounds like the lower Yukon people would agreed with it & it would make it more equitably for the rest of the subsistence users up river Canada!!!! The same goes with up river- from the 'rapids' to the Yukon bridge, shorter openings. Need to realize by F&G having those kind of 'realistic openings, it will greatly cut down on the 'sales of subsistence kings'!
ryemil
|
July 13, 2011
Well, that's about of a lame excuse I ever heard!!! Some of the brighter folks already new that there's a good chance Doug K. wasn't going to not make it because of lack of funding, maybe 3 weeks or more before fishing. Some people were told to watch out for him! In Y4A fishwheels are used on the North bank for summer chums, once in awhile a king might get caught a fishwheel. The kings in all of Y4 swim on the South bank, ask anyone that drifts for kings. Hope no one believes Doug K. excuse. That is why Y4A is one of the 'greenest' fishery's, the kings swim on the opposite side of the river that the chums. Doug K. simply didn't have the capital or backing. The Kaltag fishery suffered because of that, it was a 'bad' management year on the part of the Kaltag Fish Plant.
88888
|
July 13, 2011
Lack of jobs in villages is a major crisis in Alaska. To save 70 summer jobs, it would be well worth it to station a full-time observer in Kaltag during the king run to make sure there is no bycatch of kings. Wouldn't it make sense to make a little effort to save 70 hard-to-find jobs? It's not like these folks can get a job at the local McDonald's!
out_in_the_cold
|
July 13, 2011
The Yukon River has a commercially harvestable surplus of summer chum, and ADFG has pre-season indicated that the commercial summer chum fishery would occur this summer.

Mr. Karlberg didn't notify middle Yukon River fishers until the early party of June that he was not going to process or buy summer chum at Kaltag.

All indications of strong market demand and commercially harvestable surplus .. and still the processor bails out at the last minute?

It sounds more likely that the fish processor did not have the operating capital or financial backing to process at Kaltag, in a good year.

The live release of king salmon from the fishwheel fishery targetting abundant summer chum is the effort of the fishermen as their part of the conservation effort to provide escapement and upper river subsistence needs, not Mr. Karlberg's.
CharlieTuna
|
July 13, 2011
Mr. Hayes is now a self-proclaimed expert at the economics of fish processing.

Amazing really, as he has had zero experience at fish processing.

The last few years Adf&g Hayes has been promising early chum openings, but the record is clear he has yet to ever give early chum openings. His word cannot be trusted.

The facts are clear. Adfg asked Kaltag fishermen in writing to return the Chinook alive in return for early chum fishing. Adfg reneged on the deal.

Now Hayes falsely claims that he would have opened early even in the face of horrible Chinook salmon returns. Mr. Hayes is lying to cover his butt.

All the Chinook salmon were returned alive back into the river. There is not a record a single commercial Chinook being caught in Kaltag for the last 14 years.

Adfg Hayes cannot even compliment the Kaltag fishermen for their conservation efforts.

Mr. Hayes is playing politics, without any consideration of it's terrible effects on river communities.
doubledumb
|
July 13, 2011
Once again the blame can be laid on the Commercial Fishing Industry out in the open sea.
Newsminer.com encourages a lively exchange of ideas regarding topics in the news. Users are solely responsible for the content. Comments are not pre-approved by News-Miner staff. Please keep it clean, respect others and use the 'report abuse' link when necessary. Read our full user's agreement.